Should You Migrate from Shopify? Comparing All Four Options
Key takeaways
- Migrate from Shopify only if your all-in cost (plan plus paid apps plus transaction fees) keeps climbing, not just because the sticker price looks high.
- BigCommerce is the closest like-for-like swap, but its higher plan price means your all-in cost may not drop much.
- WooCommerce gives you the lowest software cost and the best content platform, at the price of becoming your own sysadmin.
- Magento only earns its overhead if you genuinely need complex B2B workflows like net terms and purchase orders.
- Themes, discount codes, gift cards, and customer passwords never transfer, and every product URL needs a 301 redirect to preserve SEO.
If you're paying $250-300 a month for your Shopify store and renewing soon, it's worth deciding whether to migrate from Shopify, and there are four realistic places to go: BigCommerce, WooCommerce on WordPress, Magento, or a hosted all-in-one like UnifyCart. The right pick depends on what's driving your costs, since paid apps for basic features and transaction fees are usually the problem, not Shopify itself. This guide compares all four side by side, tells you when each is the wrong choice, and walks through the exact migration steps for each path.
Should you migrate from Shopify, and to which platform?
Yes, if your all-in cost (plan plus paid apps plus transaction fees) keeps climbing while you spend afternoons untangling theme code and app conflicts. No, if your store runs fine on the apps you have and your renewal price hasn't moved. Before you decide, export your products and customers to CSV so you know exactly what you'd be moving: Shopify's help center explains the export.
The four realistic destinations
| Destination | Best fit | Wrong choice if |
|---|---|---|
| BigCommerce | Merchants who want built-in features instead of paid apps | You need heavy theme customization without a developer |
| WooCommerce / WordPress | You already run a blog or content site | You never want to touch hosting, updates, or backups |
| Magento | Larger catalogs, complex B2B needs like net terms and purchase orders | You're a 1-3 person team without a maintenance budget |
| Hosted all-in-one (UnifyCart) | You want a flat monthly subscription with checkout, payments, and tax included | You need a niche app from Shopify's ecosystem |
The one-question test: who do you want to maintain your store?
WooCommerce and Magento mean you (or a contractor you pay) handle updates, security, and hosting. BigCommerce and hosted all-in-one platforms mean the vendor does. If "apps for basic stuff that should be included by default" is your main complaint, pick a platform whose answer is built in, not another app store.
What is your all-in cost on each platform, honestly?
Worked example: a $250-300/mo Shopify stack rebuilt elsewhere
Say your current stack is a $105/mo Shopify plan, a page builder app at $29, a reviews app at $15, an email app at $20, and transaction fees eating the rest. On WooCommerce, hosting plus the same plugins might land near $80-120/mo, but you are now the one keeping WordPress updated and untangling plugin conflicts. On BigCommerce, the plan price is higher but most of those apps are built in, so the gap narrows. On UnifyCart, the Growth tier at $79/mo (UnifyCart Pricing) covers catalogue, checkout, payments, shipping rates, tax, and accounts with no paid apps for basics, which is the honest comparison: $79 flat versus the $250-300 you pay now, with the caveat that you lose whatever niche apps you have grown attached to. Run this same line-by-line rebuild against your own stack before you commit to anything, because your app list is the number that actually decides the answer.
Where the sticker price lies
Sticker price lies in both directions. A cheap plan that needs four paid apps is not cheap, and a flat subscription can still sting in slow months when you sell nothing. Before you migrate from Shopify, list every line you actually pay, then price the same list on each destination.
When is BigCommerce the right (and wrong) choice?
BigCommerce fits if you want a hosted store with most built-in features and no per-transaction fee, and you're comfortable paying a higher sticker price instead of stacking paid apps. It's the closest like-for-like swap from Shopify.
How to migrate from Shopify to BigCommerce step by step
- Export your products, customers, and orders from Shopify admin as CSV files. Note that Shopify's export and store-cancellation documentation covers what you can take with you and what stays behind.
- Open your BigCommerce account and use its built-in Shopify importer for products and customer records.
- Rebuild your theme on BigCommerce's Stencil framework; apps and theme code do not carry over.
- Set up 301 redirects for every product and collection URL, then relaunch and cancel Shopify.
When BigCommerce is the wrong choice
Skip it if your monthly budget is the core problem: BigCommerce plans cost more than Shopify's entry tiers, so your all-in cost may not drop much. It's also the wrong pick if you rely on niche Shopify apps, since you'll rebuild that functionality or lose it. If you want everything included at one flat monthly subscription instead, compare a hosted all-in-one like UnifyCart's built-in features before committing.
Can I migrate from Shopify to WordPress or WooCommerce?
Yes. WooCommerce runs on WordPress, and the core plugin is free. You pay for hosting, a theme, and any paid extensions, so your all-in cost depends on what you pick rather than what a plan includes.
How to migrate from Shopify to WooCommerce step by step
- Buy hosting that supports WordPress and install WooCommerce.
- Export products, customers, and orders from Shopify as CSV files.
- Import products with WooCommerce's built-in CSV importer, then import customers and orders with a migration plugin or a manual CSV load.
- Rebuild your checkout, shipping zones, and tax rates by hand, since those do not export cleanly.
- Redirect old Shopify URLs to your new pages before you cancel your Shopify plan.
What WordPress adds beyond the store
WordPress handles content better than any hosted store builder: landing pages, guides, and blog posts that drive search traffic. If your sales depend on content, that alone justifies the move.
When self-hosting is the wrong choice
You are now the sysadmin. Updates, backups, security, plugin conflicts, and performance are your problem, and a broken checkout waits on nobody but you. If you want to spend time selling instead of maintaining a stack, a hosted option with built-in features fits better. We cover our own tradeoffs honestly in the hosted section and on the UnifyCart blog.
How do you migrate from Shopify to Magento, and is the overhead worth it?
Migration steps in brief
Export products, customers, and orders from Shopify as CSVs, then use Magento's built-in import profiles or a paid migration tool to map them in. Rebuild your theme from scratch, since Shopify themes do not transfer. Reconfigure payment gateways, shipping rates, and tax rules manually, then test checkout end to end before cutting over. Plan for redirects: your Shopify URL structure will not carry over.
Why most small teams should skip it
Magento expects you to run it: hosting, updates, security patches, and a developer on call. For a 1-10 person team paying $250-300/mo all-in, that overhead usually costs more than the app fees you are escaping. If your real gripe is paid apps for basics and transaction fees on top of everything, a hosted platform with built-in features fits better. If you genuinely need complex B2B workflows like net terms, purchase orders, or trade accounts, Magento earns its keep; otherwise it does not. We have written before about how much order history a store really carries: PM Press moved eighteen years of orders.
What Shopify data can and cannot be migrated?
What exports cleanly via CSV
Products, customers, and orders all export from Shopify's admin as CSV files, and every serious destination platform accepts them. Product titles, SKUs, prices, inventory counts, and customer contact details transfer with minimal cleanup. CSV import is the standard route for these core objects on every platform covered here.
What needs an app or manual rework
Some objects export but arrive broken. Product images come through as URLs pointing at Shopify's CDN, so they need re-hosting before you cancel. Order histories import but rarely keep their full line-item and payment detail. Discount codes, gift cards, and your theme never transfer; you rebuild those on the destination's tools.
What you will rebuild from scratch
Customer passwords cannot be exported for security reasons, so buyers must reset them on first login. Shipping rates, tax rules, checkout customizations, and any app-built workflows (subscriptions, loyalty, trade accounts) get reconfigured by hand. Budget a day for these, not an afternoon.
How do you preserve SEO rankings when leaving Shopify?
Shopify uses fixed URL structures: /products/ and /collections/. Most alternatives don't match them, so every product page URL changes at migration. Without 301 redirects, those pages return 404s and Google drops them from results within weeks.
Map and redirect every /products and /collections URL
Export your full URL list from Shopify (products, collections, blog posts, pages), map each old URL to its new destination, and publish the redirects as a single CSV or bulk rule on the new platform. Redirect to the closest equivalent page, not the homepage. Redirect chains (old → intermediate → final) dilute value, so point old URLs directly at their final home.
Pre-launch crawl checklist
Before DNS cutover, crawl the staging site to confirm no 404s, correct canonical tags, matching title tags and meta descriptions, and a submitted XML sitemap in Search Console. After launch, watch the Pages report for a spike in "Not Found" errors and fix stragglers within the first week. Expect a temporary ranking dip of a few weeks even when everything is done right.
What does each migration cost in time, tools, and rework?
For a small team doing it themselves, expect a weekend for BigCommerce or a hosted all-in-one (products, customers, orders import in a day, then theme setup), one to two weeks part-time for WooCommerce, and a month or more for Magento before you are truly selling. WooCommerce's built-in Shopify importer handles products and customers, but orders and reviews usually need a paid connector or CSV work.
DIY vs paying a migration service
DIY costs your evenings and carries SEO risk you own. A migration service typically runs a few hundred to a couple thousand dollars depending on catalogue size; treat any quote as illustrative until they see your export files.
The rework line item nobody budgets
Theme redesign, app replacements, checkout tweaks, and rewriting meta descriptions. Merchants report losing whole afternoons to checkout and theme conflicts on their current stack; assume similar rework on the new one, and budget it before you commit.
What about hosted platforms with everything built in?
UnifyCart is the fourth path: one flat monthly subscription where the catalogue, checkout, payments, shipping rates, tax, and accounts are built in. No paid apps for basics, no transaction fees stacked on top. If your $250-300/mo all-in cost is mostly plan plus apps plus fees, the sticker price comparison is the whole comparison.
What you give up and what you stop paying for
You give up the Shopify app store and its theme ecosystem, so niche functionality may not exist and checkout customization is more limited than editing theme code. BigCommerce and WooCommerce offer larger third-party ecosystems; Ecwid and Wix eCommerce sit closer to this all-in-one model.
The honest shortcoming: UnifyCart is younger, with a smaller community and fewer guides than Shopify, so expect to file support tickets rather than search forums. If you need B2B net terms, purchase orders, or trade accounts, confirm coverage before committing. If you sell in months with no revenue, a flat subscription beats percentage fees.
FAQ
Can I migrate from Shopify to WordPress without losing my customer accounts?
Customer records, including names and email addresses, export to CSV and import into WooCommerce. Passwords cannot be exported for security reasons, so buyers must reset them on first login. Import customers with a migration plugin or a manual CSV load, and budget time to communicate the reset requirement before launch.
How long does my Shopify store stay live during a migration?
Your store stays live until you cancel the plan yourself. Build and test the new site in parallel, then cut over DNS, publish 301 redirects, and cancel Shopify only after the new platform passes your pre-launch crawl. Expect a temporary ranking dip of a few weeks even when everything is done correctly.
Do I have to cancel Shopify before or after the move?
After. Cancel before the move and you lose access to CSV exports, your URL list, and your admin. Export products, customers, and orders first, launch and verify the new site, confirm redirects work, then cancel. Shopify's own documentation covers what you can take with you and what stays behind.
Can I export my Shopify theme design to the new platform?
No. Themes never transfer, on any destination. BigCommerce requires rebuilding on its Stencil framework, WooCommerce means rebuilding on a new WordPress theme, and hosted all-in-one platforms use their own templates. Product data moves; design does not. Treat the rebuild as a redesign opportunity and budget for it as rework.
What happens to my Shopify app subscriptions when I leave?
They end when you cancel your Shopify plan, and nothing carries over. Any app-built workflows, such as subscriptions, loyalty programs, or trade accounts, must be reconfigured by hand on the new platform. Check whether each app offers its own export before cancelling, since some data may not be recoverable afterward.